From Voice ~ Topics: college, inspiration

Out of the Lab: An Interview with John Maeda

In a bold move, the Rhode Island School of Design announced in December that John Maeda, associate director of research at the MIT Media Lab, where he has served since 1996, will take over as RISD’s 16th president starting in June. Maeda has long been an advocate for humanizing technology and for marrying design and computer science in a seamless whole. As a designer he has experimented with motion typography and has developed complex systems for clients such as Cartier, Google, Philips, Reebok and Samsung. He has also authored books including Creative Code and the most recent, The Laws of Simplicity, which has been published in 14 languages. Needless to say, this announcement came as a surprise to many in the design field. How will assuming the presidency of a major design institution alter the ways Maeda works? More importantly, how will Maeda alter an institution with so much history? Although all will become clear after he assumes the seat of power, we couldn’t wait to hear his reasons for taking on this challenge and his immediate plans for the future.

Heller: John, it’s difficult to know where to start—indeed, it’s been hard to pin your career down. However, you state in your online video that you relish new things. And one constant for you has been the MIT Media Lab. Tell me about that experience and what’s prompted you to leave the fertile ground of MIT.

Click on image to play John Maeda’s RISD video.

Click on image to play John Maeda’s RISD video.

Maeda: The Media Lab is a unique singularity point in the history of academia. It was the result of combining two visions: Professor Nicholas Negroponte’s stunningly accurate prediction of digital convergence from the ’70s, together with former MIT president, the late Jerome Wiesner’s passion to contextualize science and technology in the human equation. Wiesner, having worked on the Manhattan Project, knew firsthand that technology did not live in a vacuum separate from human concerns.

I started out, first and foremost, a product of MIT and not the Media Lab. My undergrad and grad studies were in electrical engineering and computer science at MIT—after which I was at the Media Lab for a year as a PhD student, only to drop out because of a negative experience with my faculty advisor. I am always grateful to my old advisor—if it were not for him I would have never gone to art school. The “lucky accident” we often describe in making art or while designing is prevalent in life in general.

I came back to the Media Lab in 1996 to fill the shoes of the late Muriel Cooper. After 11 years, the shoes still feel quite loose, as Muriel had spent decades going after many “grails” of visual design. My interests have always been very broad. I like creating in all kinds of media, especially words like I write now. The RISD presidency seemed particularly attractive because I would then be able to broaden my interests even further. There are so many more Cooper-esque folks out there that are younger and more talented than myself, like Martin Wattenberg, Ben Fry and Casey Reas. I feel it is more their time than mine. Mine has passed in this area of visual research, but of course I still continue to dabble.

Heller: Most university or college presidents are involved with the image and wellbeing of their respective schools. They are the corporate face of the institution and also the prime fund-raisers. Your academic career has been focused on developing innovative curricula. How do you reconcile your creative needs with the conventions of a presidency? In other words, are you going to be the conventional college president?

Maeda: At the Media Lab as associate director I have been managing the Lab’s cash flow and have turned things around, with my right hand, Becky Bermont. So, fundraising and also the more important challenge of funding retention has been part of my job. In business it is often said that it is always better to effectively keep a customer versus focusing solely recruiting new customers, because your best customers do the job of selling you to new customers for free. I look forward to the fundraising challenges I face ahead.

Working on a 16-iPod piece for the Riflemaker gallery.

Heller: But you are also an artist…

Maeda: I think my MO has always been to find design and art even in the most inane tasks. If “administration design” was a field to invent, or even “administration art,” then I am up for the challenge. The number one request I heard from RISD students was, “If I am at the most creative school in the world, then I should see that reflected in the administration—no, demand it.” Innovation can play a role in any situation, I believe.

Heller: Everyone is curious to hear what went on in the meeting that convinced you to take on this role. Without betraying confidences, can you paraphrase the moment that sealed the deed?

Maeda: Really from the beginning, I thought I’d never have a chance at getting the job. Once it had materialized as a possibility I recall my wife, Kris, [jokingly] betting all my kids—five girls—that “Daddy can’t get this job.” Add to that I showed up 30 minutes late for the interview, as I was stuck in a meeting at MIT that I couldn’t leave. Somehow I got the “callback,” and after that point somehow remained during each phase of the process.

When it came to me in the end, I kept thinking how the review panels, search committee and the board were all composed of crazed innovator-types that wanted to show the world that RISD was the only place in the world that would be willing to make the leap to hyperspace. Sort of “Look at us, world—we’re going to go where no art and school and design has ever gone before!” I figured if they were willing to press the hyperspace button, then I couldn’t turn down the chance to boldly go where no artist/designer has gone before. Note that I’m not a Trekkie or anything but am known to channel James T. Kirk once in a blue moon.

Heller: I’m a Kirk fan myself. But I’m certain that the minute you considered this as real possibility you began, as Paul Rand would say, to sketch out the solution to the problem. What are the challenges you are facing?

A favorite fortune cookie quote.

Maeda: Well, I have a lot of experience and interest in how communities are designed and implemented using modern technology, but also the old-fashioned handshake. So I’ve been thinking, designing, stressing—channeling Paul every other day to find nobleness.

Heller: And can you give a hint as to your responses?

Maeda: As for hints as to where I am right now, there is a hidden online community that has launched at RISD concurrent with my announcement, called “One RISD.” In the process, I discovered some incredible human resources at RISD that executed my impossible requests in an amazingly short amount of time. It turns out that “Scotties” [or “miracle-workers”] abound at RISD and really pulled a rabbit out of the hat in technology deployments I requested, in addition to design refinement. As of today, the day before Christmas and a little over two days after the announcement, I count 252 unique visitors that span an even mixture of students, staff and faculty that are currently educating the “pre-frosh” that I am—that’s close to 7 percent of the entirety of RISD mobilized already online, and the school’s on vacation right now! The visitors keep growing.

As for what I have further down the pipeline, I will save that discussion for a later date. Sorry for the secrecy. You know, I aspire to become the Steve Jobs of university presidents [smile]. Seriously, though, I envision RISD as the Apple brand in the university world.

Heller: By taking on this institutional role, are you going to put your own creative efforts on hold? Is this a hiatus time for your talents or a repurposing of them?

Reebok x John Maeda Timetamium.

Maeda: No, people ask me that a lot right now. I plan to continue to create—to the extent that I still do my job well as president, of course. I need to create to live, so you will continue to see me do random, small projects. My recent collaboration with Reebok on the Timetanium sneaker portends some more things coming down the line from my favorite, local shoe source. I also plan to continue to show in art galleries and write books—but not at a breakneck pace.

Most people don’t realize but I have no staff of assistants for my creative work. All the books, images and objects I’ve produced were created by my two lousy hands and confused brain. So I have no overhead nor project management needs—I just need three hours or so and can make what I need to make. I’m always envious of folks with major studios like Bruce Mau or Karim Rashid that do such big, bold and amazing projects executed to perfection. I’ve always just been one guy making stuff. I figure that’s unlikely to change.

Heller: I presume that RISD has made this very bold appointment because they want to move into the future of art and design. As you see it, what is the future of art and design education?

Maeda: Don’t know yet. I have to understand what the present situation comprises. The worst thing to do is to buy a bunch of computers and install Adobe this-or-that everywhere. First of all, you’ll go broke quickly with just paying for the regular upgrade costs; secondly you’ll make the exact same images/objects that every Tom, Dick and Jane in countries from Taiwan to Turkey run natively. It all looks the same because it’s made the same. Any vision I might have for RISD would have to be about the 10–20-year future, not about now or next year.

Heller: Will you try to make RISD into a new MIT Media Lab or take a clean-slate approach?

Maeda: Clean slate, definitely. The Media Lab had been around for 20+ years now. It was at the right place and the right time, and served an incredible role in the digital revolution. I prefer to look out further and beyond, but fueled by the incredible traditional and classical core at RISD that represents more of the “what is good” versus just the more technology-centered approach of “what is new.” You see it today so often—we desire great experiences, not just new experiences.

Heller: There is a lot of talk about how teaching—and learning—will be transmitted in the digital era. Of course, distance learning has picked up steam. Do you see the old models of the academic institution changing radically? Will the campus be transformed into something else?

Maeda’s avatar in Second Life.

Maeda: Having both will be critical in the future—a great “bricks and mortar” campus and a great “clicks and bits” campus. You’re speaking to a guy that got his MBA online—it was much more difficult and rigorous than I expected as it wasn’t one of those programs where you slip your Visa card and get a diploma emailed to you in 24 hours. Over an intense, two-year experience I realized firsthand that education will, and can, be delivered in the future as an online experience, in an interactive and challenging manner. But the tools and technology for learning are still no better than the teletype technologies of the ’70s, as they are still so primitive. I see great opportunities for designers to imagine the next phase of online education—and I am for sure not talking about just things like Second Life (I’m not a big believer in VR, yet).

Heller: What’s most interesting to me about your appointment is the connection to graphic design. This discipline is not often so well represented. When David Brown was president of Art Center he came out of a graphic design world, but was not himself a graphic designer. Do you think the way graphic design has been taught is ripe for reinvention?

Maeda: I think of myself as able to span many disciplines and do not feel wed to solely graphic design. That said, I think that the ticking time bomb of our future is the explosion of information readily available and mutable to all—it is so expansive that we will never be able to fathom it all. I imagine before the book was invented, society never thought it might be possible to organize massive amounts of info as bound copy. The conceptual equivalent of the book has not yet been invented, and I’m not talking about websites here.

Heller: Along these lines, and perhaps an odd question, is this new role for you a kind of entrepreneurship? Do you look at this opportunity as one to build, not a business per se—although that is the nature of the educational institution—but a laboratory from which new ideas and models and standards must emanate?

Maeda: It’s not a lab—it is an institution comprised of a world-class university and a world-class museum. What I have going for me, and RISD, is that it is comparatively tiny compared to Stanford or MIT or Yale, and thus, in theory, more agile and nimble. Like a Cooper MINI. Maybe RISD needs a racing stripe that goes all the way across to make it look more like the racing Cooper version... hmmm.

Heller: OK, finally, on that first day or week or month that you start, what will you do?

Maeda: I will probably turn on my computer and start the day with a green tea as always. Then hit the accelerator pedal and see how fast this baby goes. I start June 2008. Stay tuned.

About the Author: Steven Heller, co-chair of the Designer as Author MFA and co-founder of the MFA in Design Criticism at School of Visual Arts, is the author of Merz to Emigre and Beyond: Avant Garde Magazine Design of the Twentieth Century (Phaidon Press). He is co-author of New Vintage Type (Thames & Hudson), Becoming a Digital Designer (John Wiley & Co.) and Teaching Motion Design (Allworth Press). His book Iron Fists: Branding the Totalitarian State (Phaidon Press) will be published this spring. www.hellerbooks.com

  1. link to this comment by Collin Reisdorf Wed Jan 09, 2008

    I'm very excited about Mr. Maeda's move to RISD. As an Interaction & Information Devigner for the past 3 years, with a Graphic Design BFA, I'm currently looking for a place to continue my education and RISD just made the short list.

  2. link to this comment by Jason Fernald Wed Jan 09, 2008

    I'm going to miss Roger Mandell :(

  3. link to this comment by Sue Kim Sat Jan 12, 2008

    John Maeda did not come from a design background he does not know anything about design. I have seen his works and it is pure eye candy. I'm concerned how RISD's design program will turn out. His students, Ben Fry and Casey Reas would have been a better candidate.

  4. link to this comment by Jason A. Tselentis Sat Jan 12, 2008

    Sue, your comment above sounds quite opinionated. Just because you feel Maeda's design is "pure eye candy", how can you say that he knows nothing about design? Maeda will become RISD's figurehead and chief administrator. The committee that elected him to do so certainly felt that he's capable, and if you denounce Maeda's soon-to-be position, then you denounce some of RISD's existing leadership.

    I argue that he will inspire and lead the institution quite successfully despite your point of view (which you are entitled to).

  5. link to this comment by tobto Sun Jan 13, 2008

    The old models of the academic institution change radically, we all know that, especially in such field as design.

  6. link to this comment by jj Sun Jan 13, 2008

    There are few brighter people in our industry than Maeda. The School is lucky to have him. The students will greatly benefit. People get hired for their portfolio, yes. But they also get hired for their thinking - I can't imagine that RISD's collective design IQ will not increase under his leadership.

  7. link to this comment by Tommy Rainwater Sun Jan 13, 2008

    This is a great move forward for RISD.

    I love Maeda's "What Is Good" vs "What Is New" approach. I wonder if he's a fan of Robert Pirsig's "Zen and the Art of Motorcycle Maintenance"?

    Here's a passage from the book that sounds like Maeda is in tune with.

    >>>What’s new?” is an interesting and broadening eternal question, but one which, if pursued exclusively, results only in an endless parade of trivia and fashion, the silt of tomorrow. I would like, instead, to be concerned with the question “What is best?,” a question which cuts deeply rather than broadly, a question whose answers tend to move the silt downstream.

    .

  8. link to this comment by J. Coates Sun Jan 13, 2008

    The center of the world moved from the early civilizations in China and Asia, to the Mediterranean empires and the Middle East, then to Britain and Europe, and finally in the last century it was solidly in North America and still remains here. For the moment.
    In the next century it is likely to be somewhere in the middle of the Pacific Ocean as India and China grow economically into modernized societies.
    Maeda is a strategic pick. A first generation Asian American academic, with degrees in science, design, and business and a well worn world traveler with international recognition. It was indeed a bold move but, I think, probably a good pick considering the many unknowns that lay ahead for the next 50 years.
    Those Reeboks are going to wear out fast with all the weight now on his shoulders and distances he will travel.

  9. link to this comment by Bill Allen Mon Jan 14, 2008

    Hoorah! A good move on RISD's part. I may actually respond to some of the alumni spam. :D

    As far as his personal art work, he's the president of the school, I can't even recall if Roger Mandell did anything except fund raise (not that I had an issue with Mandell). Honestly the actual art of the faculty has never been INCREDIBLE (good lord look at Nancy Frieze's work, suburban housewives do better). They are hired somewhat for their work but more for what they can get out of the people that they work with.

    The MIT Media Lab has been one of the real epicenters of culture in the last 15 years. Seems like his pedigree is perfect.

  10. link to this comment by Michael Chang Mon Jan 14, 2008

    Good job, RISD.

  11. link to this comment by selene Tue Jan 15, 2008

    you have a problem with suburban housewives?

  12. link to this comment by Josh Tue Jan 15, 2008

    I second Mr Tselentis's rebuttal to Sue Kim.

    I don't think the sum of his actual work is his real value to RISD or what it was to MIT.

    I think we will seem him drive RISD to parallel Stanford's D-School in terms of developing innovative programs that span majors and lead to creating problem solvers in many different fields. Not just those for Pepsi or Microsoft, but for true societal problems.

    If you wonder what benefit the fine arts majors will reap, its hard to tell. Artists that receive such degrees are very admirable as they often reflect society in ways that may or may not be comfortable through their work. These people are very impassioned people as well, but often they lack any definite skills that can often be applied in other job areas.

    I'd be interested to see what changes could be brought that would help artists maintain their quality of output, but make them more viable and employable in the future.

    Design is always seen as more practical profession, but if we didn't have such dedication to the arts, we wouldn't have any culture to speak of.

    His art may not appeal to you, but that is why art is so great. It's personal to the creator and if other people get it great, but it should be created out of a search for inner truths or pure aesthetic.

    I'd be more concerned if it weren't someone as potentially controversial.

  13. link to this comment by Sue Kim Wed Jan 16, 2008

    Design is not art. It's similar but different. Yes, design can be artful as it should be but it is not the same. Design is design because it's problem solving, it's working for a client. It's not about you, it's about somebody else. I've seen so many designers try to create personal works. It's not about self expression.

    Yes, it is important to be a conceptual designer, and that is one thing I commend John Maeda for. But just because you can think creatively does not mean the solution is effective. The most important question to ask is does it communicate. I look at his "infinity loop" or "16 ipod piece" and I wonder what the message is and whether it really communicates to the audiences.

  14. link to this comment by Ethan A. Fri Jan 18, 2008

    First, please look at his work again.
    I mean work he made as a graphic designer for companies.
    Second, he does not teach graphic design at MIT.
    What are you talking about infinity loop and 16 ipod piece?
    Finally, he will be a president of RISD not a head of graphic design department.
    Also, "design is not art" is your proposition. In fact, there are a territory that design and art hold in common. What is graphic authorship?

  15. link to this comment by T.Y. Mon Jan 21, 2008

    The greatest contribution that Roger Mandell leaves behind is a school that educates in great problem solving and process skills in art and design (with a beautiful campus). I hope that John Maeda will continue with that tradition and bring leadership and productivity, with less biases and eye-candy.

  16. link to this comment by C.B. Wed Jan 23, 2008

    The students at RISD are unanimously "very excited"
    and "thrilled" about Maeda. We cannot wait!

  17. link to this comment by j.m. Wed Jan 23, 2008

    We are excited indeed!

    John Maeda has already started interacting with students and participating actively in various projects.
    Proves not only to be a brilliant mind, but someone who is committed
    to create an environment that facilitates not only creative thinking, but the conclusion of tangible problem-solving projects.

  18. link to this comment by S.K. Fri Jan 25, 2008

    Re:
    >John Maeda did not come from a design background he >does not know anything about design.

    No background? Hmm, John Maeda had a PhD in Product Design the last time I checked.

  19. link to this comment by S.K. Fri Jan 25, 2008

    I think that there is every reason for RISD to be pumped for this change :]

    I'm always amazed how some designers can be so snarky in the face of a brave, new idea. Heaven did not deliver unto mankind a definition of design, and the early modernists that set the pace for today were notoriously fickle in their beliefs. Plus, I think that defining design as impersonal creative work for a client is a sadly constrained box to fit in such a spectrum of efforts.

    Personally, I would instead say that it is the science of making the world work more like art.

  20. link to this comment by Gerard Sat Jan 26, 2008

    I graduated from RISD in 1970, so I have some perspective. Organisms that don't evolve or mutate die, period. I think Maeda is an unexpectedly brilliant chess move on the school's part. Bravo.

  21. link to this comment by rm Sun Jan 27, 2008

    Sue stated that "Design is not art. It's similar but different. Yes, design can be artful as it should be but it is not the same. Design is design because it's problem solving, it's working for a client. It's not about you, it's about somebody else. I've seen so many designers try to create personal works. It's not about self expression."

    I agree that design must communicate to be effective. The primary purpose for design is to communicate. However, why can design not be art? Why can it not be personal? Art communicates. Art speaks. It transcends all language barriers and it speaks at a very personal level. I feel that removing personal expression from design hinders our ability to make a true impact or connection with our audience.

    Additionally, many here have tried to define what design is, and the fact that there are differing opinions proves that it is not something that can be described definitively. Yes, certain areas of design are easier to comprehend. I know what logo design is. I know what interior design is. However, the larger scope of design is a much more loosely defined concept, now more than ever. It has become a concept and a profession without boundaries. There will always be designers with specialties, but I feel that the great designers that will emerge will take a much more comprehensive and collaborative approach. The mediums by which we will communicate will be quite different and unique. I look forward to seeing Maeda contribute to the direction of communication.

    Maybe instead of trying to figure out what design is, we should be asking ourselves what design can become. What avenues for communication have we missed with our tunnel vision?

  22. link to this comment by kristin Mon Jan 28, 2008

    design is a commercial art.

    I graduated MFA '00 and I had the opportunity to see Maeda's small lecture on the beauty in technology which had an impact on how I wanted to approach my thesis. Considering that my department was primarily dinosaurs and didn't really want to explore the moving image as a medium,(mostly because they didn't have the knowledge) it was a very difficult process and uphill battle. I graduated on the eve of the establishment of Digital Design programs. Ahead of my time then but RISD is right on time and I applaud this move.

    btw. part of the main duties for a college/university president is to fundraise. How else is he/she going to be able to push their agendas, programs etc. .

  23. link to this comment by Sara Wed Jan 30, 2008

    I was excited to hear the news as a '06 design grad of RISD. I wish I was there to experience the changes that the school will undergo, and I definitely feel they will be for the positive.

  24. link to this comment by hardy Wed Jan 30, 2008

    I speak as a professional designer, a practicing fine artist, someone familiar with Cambridge as well as someone who had the chance to meet John at the last AIGA conference in Boston.

    HE IS A VISIONARY!
    RISD is MIGHTY lucky to have plucked him from the dynamism of Cambridge!

    He is a humble, incredibly talented, and a highly energetic soul. He has not taken the easy route, nor been spoon fed by anyone.

    RHODE ISLAND better take care of him because MASSACHUSETTS was proud to have him among us---pursuing whatever he felt the need to pursue.

    In this information glutted world we need an interdisciplinary visionary who can help the world understand the value of communication with smarts, dignity, clarity and the eye for beauty.

    I could think of no one else who deserves this position (and who once and for all will make me wish I was an alum because I turned down entry many years ago).

    In this position he can bring his multiplicity to the fore because it is indeed what the best design is made from—a convergence of many paths.

    Your going to fly!

  25. link to this comment by slm Thu Jan 31, 2008

    Sue>> "Design is not art."

    This statement makes this a truly sad sad day for graphic design, in the future of our presence, and also the day you actually paid for a membership.

    I'm glad you have an opinion - but what a small closed box you live inside.

  26. link to this comment by e Mon Feb 04, 2008

    I think that you are the one in the small box because instead of critically analyzing Sue’s statement, you are completely ignoring it because it goes against some personal principle. For many designers, design is not art, that doesn’t mean that design is not part of a bigger, mightier entity but that it differentiates itself from art as a different cultural expression.

Add a Comment

AIGA encourages thoughtful, responsible discourse. Please add comments judiciously, and refrain from maligning any individual, institution or body of work.